Spike Lee, a renowned filmmaker and Academy Award winner, has been vocal about his criticism of the film Green Book. Released in 2018, Green Book became a popular and highly acclaimed movie, winning multiple awards, including the coveted Best Picture at the Oscars. However, despite its success and positive reception from many, Spike Lee has expressed his strong disapproval of the film. Let’s dive deeper into the reasons behind Spike Lee’s disdain for Green Book.
1. Historical Accuracy
One of the main points of criticism from Spike Lee is the question of historical accuracy. Green Book tells the story of a friendship between African-American pianist Dr. Don Shirley and his Italian-American driver Tony Vallelonga during a concert tour in the 1960s Deep South. While the film portrays a heartwarming bond between the two characters, Lee argues that it simplifies and sanitizes the harsh realities of racism and segregation during that time.
Lee, known for his examination of racial tensions and social issues in his films, believes that Green Book misses the mark in presenting a realistic understanding of the racial dynamics of the era. He argues that the movie, despite good intentions, focuses more on the white character’s perspective and perpetuates the “white savior” trope.
2. Lack of Authenticity
Spike Lee also takes issue with the film’s lack of involvement from Shirley’s family in the making of the movie. Dr. Shirley’s surviving family members have distanced themselves from the project, stating that they were never consulted or given proper representation. This absence of authentic input from the individuals who knew Shirley best undermines the film’s credibility in the eyes of Lee.
Furthermore, in an interview following his Oscar win for Best Adapted Screenplay for his film BlacKkKlansman, Spike Lee referred to Green Book’s win for Best Picture as a “bad call.” This comment only solidifies his belief that the film is not a true representation of Black experiences and is instead a Hollywood-friendly version of racial reconciliation.
3. Diversity and Inclusion Issues
In recent years, discussions around diversity and inclusion in the film industry have gained significant prominence. Spike Lee has been a leading voice in advocating for more opportunities for marginalized communities, both in front of and behind the camera. His criticism of Green Book extends to the lack of diversity in its production team.
The film was directed by white filmmaker Peter Farrelly and predominantly written by white writers. Lee argues that the film’s perspective could have been more authentic and nuanced with a diverse creative team, capable of capturing the complexities of racial dynamics with greater sensitivity.
4. Comparison to Driving Miss Daisy
It is worth mentioning that Spike Lee’s criticism of Green Book also draws parallels to his distaste for the 1989 film Driving Miss Daisy, which won the Academy Award for Best Picture that year. In both cases, Lee accuses the films of downplaying systemic racism in favor of a feel-good narrative driven by a white character.
Lee, as a filmmaker known for his bold and uncompromising exploration of race-related issues, believes that these films perpetuate a harmful narrative by diminishing the severity and impact of racial inequality.
Credit: www.hollywoodreporter.com
Credit: deadline.com
In Conclusion
While Green Book received critical acclaim and amassed a significant audience base, Spike Lee’s objections highlight the complexities of interpreting and portraying historical events, especially those related to race. His criticisms regarding historical accuracy, lack of authenticity, diversity and inclusion, and comparison to Driving Miss Daisy showcase his commitment to addressing complex social issues through film.
Spike Lee’s perspectives challenge the mainstream narrative and encourage discussions that dive deeper into the nuances of representation and storytelling, ultimately aiming for a more accurate and inclusive portrayal of marginalized communities on screen.
Frequently Asked Questions Of Why Does Spike Lee Hate Green Book?
Why Does Spike Lee Hate Green Book?
Green Book has been criticized for its historical inaccuracies and the portrayal of race relations.
What Are The Main Criticisms Of Green Book?
Critics argue that the film perpetuates the “white savior” trope and downplays the real struggles faced by African Americans.
How Did The Controversy Impact Green Book’s Reception?
The controversy surrounding the film intensified after it won the Academy Award for Best Picture, leading to further debates on its portrayal of racial issues.
