Joe Montana is often considered one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, and many people believe he was better than Tom Brady. Montana was known for his precision passing and ability to perform in clutch situations, leading his teams to victory in four Super Bowls. Some people argue that Montana’s stats and overall impact on the game make him a superior quarterback to Brady.
5 reasons Why Joe Montana is Better Than Brady?
Joe Montana and Tom Brady are widely regarded as two of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, but many people believe Montana was the better player. In this article, we’ll explore 5 reasons why Montana is considered the superior quarterback, including his higher winning percentage, efficiency with the ball, playoff success, individual accolades, and style of play.
Montana had a higher winning percentage
One reason why many people believe Joe Montana was a better quarterback than Tom Brady is because of Montana’s higher winning percentage. Throughout his career, Montana had a winning percentage of .739, while Brady’s career winning percentage is .773. While a higher winning percentage does not necessarily mean that a quarterback is definitively better than another, it can be seen as a more important indicator of a quarterback’s overall success and impact on their team. Montana’s ability to consistently lead his team to victories played a major role in his legendary status.
Montana was more efficient with the ball
Another reason why Joe Montana is often considered a superior quarterback to Tom Brady is because of his efficiency with the ball. Montana had a touchdown-to-interception ratio of 2.23, meaning he averaged over two touchdowns for every interception he threw. In comparison, Brady’s touchdown-to-interception ratio is 1.93. Montana’s ability to minimize turnovers and protect the ball was a key factor in his success, as it allowed his team to maintain possession and score points. This efficiency was particularly evident in the playoffs, where Montana’s teams were able to capitalize on opportunities and come out on top.
Montana was more successful in the playoffs
Another factor that sets Joe Montana apart from Tom Brady is his success in the playoffs. Montana had a playoff record of 16-7 and won four Super Bowls, while Brady has a playoff record of 32-11 and has won seven Super Bowls. While both players have impressive playoff records, the number of Super Bowl victories is often seen as the ultimate measure of a quarterback’s success. Montana’s ability to perform at a high level and lead his team to victory in the biggest games solidified his reputation as one of the best clutch performers in NFL history.
Montana had more individual accolades
Joe Montana also has more individual accolades than Tom Brady, which is another reason why some people believe he was the better quarterback. Montana was a three-time Super Bowl MVP and a two-time NFL MVP, while Brady has only won one Super Bowl MVP and four NFL MVP awards. In addition to these awards, Montana was also selected as a first-team All-Pro four times, while Brady has only been selected twice. These individual accolades reflect a quarterback’s overall skill and impact on their team, and Montana’s numerous awards demonstrate his consistently high level of play throughout his career.
Montana’s style of play was more conducive to team success
Finally, Montana’s style of play was often seen as more conducive to team success than Brady’s. Montana was known for his precision passing and ability to execute in key moments, which helped his teams consistently come out on top. In contrast, Brady has often relied on his receivers and a strong defense to win games. While both players have had success with their respective styles of play, Montana’s leadership and clutch performance was a major factor in his team’s victories. His ability to take control of the game and make smart decisions under pressure was a key part of his success as a quarterback.
Joe Montana Vs Tom Brady (Comparisons)
- Winning percentage: Joe Montana had a career winning percentage of .739, while Tom Brady’s career winning percentage is .773.
- Touchdown-to-interception ratio: Joe Montana had a ratio of 2.23, while Tom Brady’s is 1.93.
- Playoff success: Joe Montana had a playoff record of 16-7, won 4 Super Bowls and named Super Bowl MVP twice. While Tom Brady has a playoff record of 32-11, won 7 Super Bowls and named Super Bowl MVP 5 times.
- MVP awards: Joe Montana won 2 NFL MVP awards, while Tom Brady has won 4.
- All-Pro selections: Joe Montana was selected 4 times as a first-team All-Pro, while Tom Brady was selected twice.
- Super Bowl wins: Joe Montana has 4 Super Bowl wins, while Tom Brady has 7.
- Career longevity: Tom Brady played for 21 seasons, while Joe Montana only played for 15 seasons.
- Passing yards: Tom Brady has passed for over 79,000 yards, while Joe Montana has passed for over 40,000 yards.
- Passing touchdowns: Tom Brady has thrown for over 581 touchdowns, while Joe Montana has thrown for over 273 touchdowns.
- Post-season passer rating: Joe Montana has a passer rating of 95.6 in post-season, While Tom Brady has a passer rating of 95.9 in post-season.
Joe Montana Vs Tom Brady Stats
Here is a list of statistics for Joe Montana and Tom Brady, in a 3 column format:
| Statistic | Joe Montana | Tom Brady |
|---|---|---|
| Winning percentage | .739 | .773 |
| TD-INT ratio | 2.23 | 1.93 |
| Playoff record | 16-7 | 32-11 |
| Super Bowl wins | 4 | 7 |
| NFL MVP awards | 2 | 4 |
| All-Pro selections | 4 | 2 |
| Seasons played | 15 | 21 |
| Passing yards | 40,551 | 79,204 |
| Passing touchdowns | 273 | 581 |
| Post-season passer rating | 95.6 | 95.9 |
Please note that the statistics provided are one way to compare these two players, as it does not take into account other aspects of their game such as leadership, game management, and overall impact on the game.
What Does Joe Montana Think of Tom Brady?
It is unclear what Joe Montana’s current opinion of Tom Brady specifically is, but in the past he has spoken positively about the quarterback. In various interviews, he has praised Brady for his work ethic, consistency, and success over the years. Montana has also acknowledged the high level of skill and competitiveness that both he and Brady share, recognizing them as some of the best to ever play the game. He also has said that he enjoys watching him play and he is a big fan of his. As professional athletes and legends of the game, they are often compared against one another and Joe Montana has recognized Tom Brady’s achievements and his own admiration for him.
Conclusion
In conclusion, there are several reasons why many people believe Joe Montana was a better quarterback than Tom Brady. Montana had a higher winning percentage, was more efficient with the ball, more successful in the playoffs, had more individual accolades, and his style of play was more conducive to team success.
While both players have had incredibly successful careers, Montana’s precision passing and ability to perform in clutch situations set him apart as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. Additionally, his records and individual achievement speak for themselves. It’s worth noting that, these statistics and comparisons are one way to measure the skill of these players, but ultimately the debate over who was the better quarterback will continue, both players are considered as NFL legends and one of the best players in NFL history.
